MAIN GUIDES REVIEWS GALLERY LINKS CONTACT
Climb Guide > Reviews > Belay Devices

Belaying has been around as long as ropes have been used, albeit in a different form to the modern systems. It seems ludicrous the way the pioneers climbed. They simply tied some rope round their waist and simple hooked it over nodules in the rock as protection. Belays consisted of a ledge, or crack that allowed the belayer to relax without holding onto the rock. They did not use any form of gear to link them with the rock. I have evidence of this lunacy in an ancient climbing guide to Buchille Etive Mor. If a climber fell off, unless the belay was unusually sound, both of them would hurtle downwards. This was often avoided by the easy angle of the climbs, allowing the leader to catch himself. The actual method of belaying was either a waist belay or shoulder belay. Both being painful, but the shoulder belay is potentially harmful. On southern sandstone crags not much has changed for some. A few people climb with a rope loosely tied round the waist, and using a waist belay.

I think that the waist belay is still a useful technique to have. To waist belay you hold the live rope in your weaker hand, and pass the dead end round your waist. Wrap your stronger arm round the rope once or twice. To lock off you simple bring your stronger arm across your body, thus increasing friction. I suggest a thick jumper is worn to reduce the pressure from the rope.

The direct belay has always been used, and will probably continue to be used. It is simply when the rope is wrapped round a block or spike, and the friction is generated by the rope rubbing on the rock. The major consideration is that the block is solid, also that the rope will not flick out if the direction of pull changes. I find this technique particularly useful in long easy climbs, when there are a lot of pitches to cover and time is of the essence. This technique allows you to move a lot quicker than if belays were set up at every stop.

Italian Hitch

The Italian Hitch was the first proper device used for belaying. It is a personal favourite, that I use quite often. It is especially useful as a direct belay system, when it is tied directly to an anchor. This is good as it allows all the force of a fall, to be transferred direct to the anchors. The knot works well as it is locked off in front of the knot, not behind. This makes a less jumbled belay. The hitch has to be used with an HMS krab so the knot can rotate freely. The HMS krab was designed for the knot and stands for Halb Mastwurf Sicherung, which roughly translates as half securing knot. One problem with the knot is that it has a tendency to twist and kink the rope. Also it generates friction by rubbing the rope against itself. Which could ware the rope out, but I have had no such problem.

Camp Sticht Plate : 64g, 9-11mm (Below left)

Salewa invented the principles behind most modern day belay devices in the early 70's, with the original sticht plate. This had a tendency to jam, so a spring was added, thus relieving the problem. The sticht plate is still very good, but there are more refined devices around. Although I find it a useful piece of kit, as it works well and is fairly cheap. The only slight problem comes when the device is used as a descender, as there is not much metal, it gets quite hot. Actually it gets too hot to hold, if you descend quickly.

Camp Tuber : 50g, 9-11mm (Above Right)
(Equipment Problems)

This was the first device to appear that did not use the plate design, although the actual process was the same. It is an offset tube with a bar across its middle, thus coping for twin ropes. Also the sides are ribbed, which help dissipate heat very well. I find is a very good device, as it seems to have a lot of holding power. Recently I have lost a little faith in the device. This is due to the design of the centre bar. The bar is hollow so the device can be threaded and tied to the krab, thus stopping the device moving up the rope. As the device gets used more, grooves are worn into the bar, when these ware through, razor sharp edges appear which can cut the rope in an instance. But it does take a long time for this sort of thing to happen. Also a HMS krab should be used, as it does not disappear up into the device, so maximum friction is generated.

DMM Bug :58g, 9-11mm

I used to own one of these but Alan accidentally dropped it off Middle Fell Buttress in Langdale, when I was first showing him how to lead. The bug now seems to be his favourite device. I find it to be very smooth and locks very nicely. It is essentially an extruded sticht plate. The spring is simply replaced with a solid tube that keeps the krab away from the slots. But similarly to the Tuber, a HMS krab works best.

Wild Country Variable Controller : 63g, 8-11mm

This is very similar to the sticht plate, minus the spring. The main difference being that the cross section is a wedge shape. This makes an enormous difference and provides a very smooth operation. The orientation of the device varies the amount of friction and holding power. I think it works very well, but there is not really anything outstanding about it. The Bug seems to be that little bit smoother, maybe a little bit too smooth.

Clog Figure Of Eight : 80g, 9-11mm
(Equipment Problems)

This was the original device designer solely for abseiling. It works exceptionally well as a descender, but also can be used as a belay device. Abseiling on double ropes is fine but belaying double ropes is almost impossible. This is because it is very hard to take in one rope at a time. Some people find it belays a single rope best by using the krab hole as a typical plate. There is enough metal to dissipate the heat from a long fast abseil. But buying a device specifically for abseiling is a bit extravagant, as most belay plates will work almost as well.

DMM Cardiac Arrester : 100g, 8.2-12mm

Basically the same as the figure of eight, except a slightly tweaked shape. The krab hole has been stretched to work better as a belay device. Also the main hole has been bent, to reduce the chance of larks footing the device. This is when the rope round the neck flicks up and locks the device solid. There is not quite enough room to use double ropes easily. But it does work very well with a single rope. Due to the limitations I see no reason for this device as a sticht plate design does it all, and more.